What is the implication of the reviewer withholding the identity of the original appraiser?

Withholding the identity of the original appraiser can indeed ensure that the focus remains on the quality of the appraisal itself rather than on the individual who performed it. When the review process is conducted without disclosing the appraiser's identity, it minimizes the potential for bias or preconceived notions about the work based on the reputation or past performances of that appraiser. This practice encourages a more objective evaluation of the appraisal report based solely on the data, methodology, and conclusions presented.

By focusing on the content and quality of the appraisal, the reviewer can more effectively assess the accuracy and appropriateness of the appraisal without being influenced by personal opinions or relationships. This enhances the integrity of the review process and encourages a fair assessment based on merit rather than identity.